If compressed air is the fourth utility, energy is its dominant cost. Matching the compressor to your load profile is the fastest lever to cut kWh without compromising production. This article shows when a fixed-speed (FS) or variable speed drive (VSD) screw compressor wins—using three real-world demand shapes, simple math, and practical checklists.
- Fixed‑speed screw (FS): runs at one speed; cycles between load (full power) and unload (no air but still consuming power). Simple and robust; best near full load when sized correctly.
- VSD screw: matches motor speed to demand within a turndown range, minimising unload time and allowing tighter pressure bands—typically best under variable or intermittent demand.
- Energy = ∑ Power(t) × Δt
- For FS, Power(t) ≈ P_load when producing and ≈ P_unload when idle (often 25–35% of load power).
- For VSD, Power(t) follows a speed/flow curve; savings increase as you avoid unloaded running and trim pressure (rule of thumb ≈ 8% power per 1 bar reduction).
1) Steady, near‑full‑load production (90–100% demand)
FS : █████████████████████████████████████
VSD : ███████████████████████████████████
At truly steady, near‑full load and correct sizing, FS can match VSD. In many plants, however, measured demand varies through the day; modern VSDs typically retain an efficiency even at stable setpoints—by eliminating start/stop and enabling tighter pressure bands.
2) “Sawtooth” demand (30–80% with frequent ramps)
FS : ███████░░░░███████░░░░███████░░░░
VSD : █████▆████▅████▃███▂███▁██▁▁██
VSD typically wins by reducing unload time and narrowing pressure bands—both big kWh drivers.
3) Intermittent / shift‑based demand (long lows, short peaks)
FS : ███░░░░░░░░░░░█████░░░░░░░░░░░███
VSD : ███▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁████▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁▁███
VSD again, unless you reconfigure the system (FS base + VSD trim, more storage, smarter staging) to avoid long unloaded running.
- Demand shape: ≥85–90% and flat → shortlist fixed‑speed; variable or intermittent → shortlist VSD (or VSD trim).
- Pressure band:If you can lower set‑point by 0.5–1.0 bar with VSD & storage, expect material kWh savings (typical ranges; always confirm with measurement/logging).
- Unload time: Long idle/unload stretches favor VSD or an FS+VSD hybrid.
- Peaks: Use receiver capacity and VSD trim to ride peaks without oversizing your base machine.
- Controls: If you run a mixed room, enable VSD to start priority in the controller and verify pressure bands.
Enter your annual hours spent in each demand band. The model estimates relative energy index (FS vs VSD). For a live calculator with formulas, use the companion Excel file included.
| Band | Demand range | Hours per year | FS relative power | VSD relative power |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 80–100% (steady/high) | 1.00 | 1.02 | |
| B | 30–80% (ramps) | 1.20 | 0.90 | |
| C | 0–30% (idle/low) | 1.50 | 0.95 | |
| Total kWh index = Σ(Hours×Power) / baseline hours | ||||
Instructions: Fill "Hours per year" for bands A–C. Multiply hours by the relative power in each column and sum to compare FS vs VSD. Lower index wins. For precise results, use your compressor maps and site measurements.
How do VSD compressors save energy during variable or intermittent demand?
Consider adding receiver capacity or using a VSD "trim" compressor to handle peaks. This allows your base machine to run efficiently without oversizing, and the VSD unit can respond rapidly to demand changes.
What is a "sawtooth" demand profile, and which compressor handles it best?
Use the provided quick kWh estimator: enter your annual operating hours in each demand band (high, mid, low), multiply by the relative power values for FS and VSD, sum the totals, and compare. The lower total indicates the more energy-efficient option.
How can I quickly estimate potential energy savings between FS and VSD?
"Sawtooth" demand refers to regular, frequent shifts between medium and high airflow requirements. VSD compressors are generally more efficient in these conditions by quickly adjusting output and reducing idle losses.
What strategies can improve compressed air efficiency during peak demand?
VSD compressors excel when demand frequently ramps up and down or during long periods of low usage. They minimize unload time and keep pressure bands tighter, leading to significant kWh savings compared to fixed-speed models in these scenarios.
Where can I find more detailed guidance or tools for compressor selection and optimization?
If your facility experiences steady, near-full-load demand (typically 85–90% or higher) with minimal fluctuations, a fixed-speed compressor can perform as efficiently as a VSD unit. However, always confirm with actual demand measurements for the most accurate choice.
Can we help you find the right air compressor for your air tools?
MARK offers a wide array of air compressors which are ideal for diverse purposes. We’d be glad to help you find the right one. Just get in touch with us!
-
Filter articles by tags
